The Battle of the Bays: 50 Aunt Dottys + 50 Wellfleets


( / )

Please select all options.

Notify me when this product is available:

This package includes oysters from two of the most famed oyster regions in Massachusetts.  We've had plenty of customers who just can't decide.  And, we get it.  We have the utmost respect for both towns, oysters and growers, and we're excited to be able to let you try both at your next gathering.

This package includes 50 Aunt Dottys and 50 Wellfleets.

Aunt Dotty Oysters:

Aunt Dotty Oysters, the younger cousin of Island Creeks, are one of our most treasured creations. Small, savory and sweet - these are easy oysters to open and easy oysters to love. 

Farmer:  Skip Bennett

Location: Saquish Neck, MA

Size: 2"-2.5" consistent cull

How they’re grown: Aunt Dotties spend their 3-year grow out in trays on the tidal flats at Saquish Neck. The farm has an extremely unique location, but the best part is that it can be easily accessed year-round, unlike some of its other Duxbury Bay neighbors.  Due to long tides at the mouth of the bay, the trays will always be exposed from the water twice a day for 3-4 hours, so the crew can harvest all year-round.  A bonus?  The crew can also reach the farm via truck from Saquish beach.

Every December, the farm crew removes the oysters from the water to avoid freezing cold temps and exposure and stores them in relative comfort in burlap bags in the cellar of a little cottage that Skip owns just feet from the flats.  In April, the oysters make the short commute back to the water to pick up growing right where they left off.

How they taste: Although they’re grown only a 20-minute boat ride away from the ICO’s and Row 34’s, Aunt Dottys have a vastly different flavor!  Intensely salty up front with a nori, seaweed-like brine, they mellow into a rich, nutty sweetness, almost like a bitter walnut.  Dotties have petite cups but are bursting with dense meats giving you a super toothsome bite.  

Why they’re unique:  The land and marshes that host the farm have been in the Bennett family for generations.  Legend has it that the deed once had to be translated from Old English!  Skip plans to diversify the farm in the future, with clams and scallops, but for now, the Aunt Dotties are the inaugural offering and a sign of great things to come!

Story:  So who is the person behind the name?  Skip’s aunt, Dotty, was the original resident of the Bennett family cottage out at Saquish.  In the 1940s, Dotty and her husband lived entirely off the grid with no running water or electricity...and their 6 children.  Dotty’s husband was a lobsterman, and after he passed, Dotty kept the family business going on her own.  Dotty was a hearty, tenacious, special woman and her spirit lives on through the oyster that now bears her name.

Wellfleet Oysters

Farmer: Barbara and Clint Austin, Mike Devasto and a handful of other growers

Location: Wellfleet, MA

Size: A perfectly petite oyster from Wellfleet, MA

Farming Technique: Grown at the mouth of a creek running from a salt pond, these oysters are placed in bags on racks on the bottom for grow-out.  The creek water gets combined with big, fast moving tides that provide a crisp and clean shot of ocean in every swig.

Unique Factor: Wellfleet is a famous oyster town; however, there are nearly a hundred small growers in Wellfleet and their oysters span the full gamut in terms of quality and taste.  Wellfleets are the best at providing an esteemed, notorious and classic New England oyster experience.  They are a standby on any oyster platter--like the ex that you just keep coming back to time and again.  They never get old.

Salinity: Wellfleets are well known for their high salinity and their clean, simple finish.

Flavor Notes: High salt with a briny splash of crisp mineral water.