Excellent decision
"Purchased well fleet vs Duxbury, they where both delicious, they where a huge success, thank you Island Creek."
Duxbury VS Wellfleet
Sale Price: $239.00
( / )
Unavailable
Please select all options.
Sale Price:
$109.00
Sale Price:
$33.00
A head-to-head matchup between two of the most storied and heavy hitting oyster towns in the Bay State. Would honestly pay to see that parking lot boxing match.
50 Island Creek oysters from Duxbury, MA
50 Wellfleet oysters from Wellfleet, MA
Overall rating: 4.7011495 / 5 from 87 reviews.
AI Generated Review Summary
Customers highly praised the oysters from Duxbury and Wellfleet for their amazing flavor and fantastic taste. The service was noted as excellent and top-notch. Shipping was fast and free with excellent packaging and delivery. Wellfleet oysters were preferred over Duxbury due to their brine and veggie finish.
Summary topics
- oyster quality: 41%
- customer service: 8%
- shipping speed: 8%
- Wellfleet oyster preference: 16%
Review topics: ["size","flavor","quality","order","shipping","price","packaging","service","combo","batch","oysters","wellfleets","duxbury","island creek","side","meat","ordering","hit","shells","differences","combination","pairing"].
Review highlights
- "Shipping was fast and free and the oysters arrived safely in a well constructed, cold package." —
- "The oysters arrived perfectly on time for my birthday." —
- "Fantastic tasting oysters" —
Reviews
50/50
"Ordered these for oyster tasting party. Wellfleet was so, so sandy. Will never order them again. Duxbury were still sandy, but little bit."
Fantastic!
"We are so happy that we ordered these oysters. It was the highlight of our New Year’s Eve party. I can’t wait to order again. They were absolutely delicious and arrived exactly on time."
Favorite mix
"We really enjoyed this mix of oysters. Immediately noticed the salty brime flavor. Had a little bit of a hard time opening, however after a day in the refrigerator, opened perfectly. We enjoyed with bloody Mary's, fresh paired with kelchner's horseradish and Rockefeller. Favorite combination"
Awesome pairing. The group was
"Awesome pairing. The group was split down the middle on which preferred the Island Creeks versus the Wellfleets !"
Awesome, as always. We got
"Awesome, as always. We got the Duxbury vs Wellfleet combo. Both so good. The jury is still out so we will just have to try another round!!"
Fresh and delicious oysters delivered
"Fresh and delicious oysters delivered on time to my door…awesome!"
"On time and fresh as always!"
Two great oysters delivered on
"Two great oysters delivered on time and without issue."
Great price for both
"Great price for both"