Home All All products (collection) Pemaquid Large Oysters from Damariscotta, ME
Oyster harvester standing at a boat rail on a sunny day near Damariscotta, Maine
Close-up of Pemaquid oysters held in a fisherman’s hands showcasing rough fluted shells on a sunlit wooden dock
Pemaquid Large Oysters from Damariscotta, ME
Pemaquid Large Oysters from Damariscotta, ME
Pemaquid Large Oysters from Damariscotta, ME
Two harvesters hoisting a crate of Pemaquid oysters from a small boat to a wooden dock in Damariscotta, Maine
Oyster farm dock and shingled oyster house on a wooden pier at Pemaquid in Damariscotta, Maine, with buoys in the water and trees on the shore

Pemaquid Large Oysters from Damariscotta, ME

$140.00

( / )
Unavailable

DON'T FORGET!

Shuck set
Top-down view of shuck set with orange-handled recycled ocean-plastic shucking knife and blue gloves on white background
SALE!
Shuck Set
Sold Out
Kelchner's horse radish
Front view of 6.5 fl oz Kelchner’s Horse-Radish glass jar showing white label and pale grated horseradish on white background
Kelchner's Horse-Radish
Sale Price: $10.00
Sweet reaper hot sauce
Front view of 8 fl oz Sweet Reaper hot sauce bottle, cream label with red illustration, orange sauce, white background
Sweet Reaper Hot Sauce
Sold Out

FREE SHIPPING!

Please select all options.

Quantity: 50 Count | $2.80 per Oyster
INTERESTED IN WHOLESALE PRICING FOR THIS PRODUCT?

CONTACT OUR WHOLESALE DIVISION

Availability:

Farmer: Smokey "my mother called me Jeff" McKeen

Size: ~

Mostly due to age and the immense care the Pemaquid guys give to the process of farming these--bottom planting and cold water finishing--the most remarkable quality of these oysters is their texture. They are plump, firm, and crisp.

About Pemaquid Oysters

Harvest location: Damariscotta River, Maine

How they’re grown: These oysters are harvested after two years on the bottom and moved into floating baskets near the cold, salty mouth of the Damariscotta to condition before shipping.

Why they’re unique: Other than Duxbury Bay, the Damariscotta is one of the few growing areas on the East Coast where bottom-planting is the norm. That does two things: it makes the farmer's life significantly more difficult and imparts tons of awesome sea-vegetable and earthy flavor!

Story: These are the famous Pemaquid oysters. Their reputation precedes them and their name is bigger than their production, which means they are pretty scarce. It is not common practice for Mainers to sell their good product out of state. Lucky for you, we pulled some strings.

⚠ Prop 65 Warning

Consuming this product can expose you to chemicals including lead, which are known to the State of California to cause cancer and birth defects or other reproductive harm. For more information go to www.P65Warnings.ca.gov.

Oyster FAQ

How long do my oysters keep?

Your oysters keep in the refrigerator for 5-7 days!  You can order a day or two early to make sure you have them in time for your gathering.  They are totally fine hangin’ out in the cool air.  

How do I store these bad boys?

When you receive your package, pull them out of the box (these guys need a little fresh air!). Grab a mixing bowl and throw the mesh bag in the bowl so that the oysters don’t leak all over your refrigerator. Grab a damp cloth and throw the cloth over the bowl.  You are good to go for the next 5-7 days. Doesn’t hurt to dampen the cloth each day to keep them moist and chilled.

Should I keep them on ice?

Only put the oysters on ice before service.  The oysters will actually die in the melted fresh water so do not store the oysters on ice.  They will not like this.

How are they shipped?

We ship using FedEx Overnight service. You will receive tracking info after the label has been printed the day before your oysters are set to arrive.  We do not require a signature – Fedex will leave your package at your doorstep.

Is your packaging recyclable?

Short answer: YES!

Our ClimaCell thermal liners are made of 90% FSC certified virgin kraft paper and corn starch, which allows you to recycle the insulated liner at home along with the cardboard box.⁠
⁠
Not only are the liners water repellant, they’re just as insulating as traditional styrofoam AND they can be recycled up to 5 times. Saving the planet has never been easier.⁠

Click here for more information on ClimaCell.

Overall rating: 4.8974357 / 5 from 78 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

Pemaquid Large Oysters from Damariscotta, ME, are highly praised for their exceptional texture, unique bottom-planting method, and rich flavor. Customers appreciate the quality and care put into their cultivation, making these oysters a sought-after delicacy.

Summary topics

  • Oyster Quality (64%): Many customers remarked that these oysters are the best they have ever had from Island Creek Oysters.
  • Flavor Profile (18%): A significant number of customers pointed out that the flavor of the product is great and salty.
  • Order Satisfaction (16%): A significant amount of customers expressed satisfaction with the order, stating that they would order again.

Review topics: [size, flavor, quality, work, shipping, texture, order, service, oysters, cups, jewels, brine, shells, clams, finish, flavor profile].

Review highlights

  • "Nice pocket, size, texture and taste." — ANINA B.
  • "Oysters were nice size clean and briny." — Daniel F.
  • "These oysters were fat and firm with great brine!!" — Randy B.

Reviews

Fantastic oysters!

"Pemaquid oysters were amazing. All 50 that we received were in perfect condition. Plump and firm, with nice deep cups. Incredible flavor and a nice salty brine. Fresh oysters don't come better than this."

— GHP (5/5)

Very fine Pemaquid oysters

"The 50 oyster bag of Pemaquid was my first order with Island Creek Oysters. The order arrived exactly as advertised perfectly packed with frozen gel packs in a very well insulated box. The gel pads were still frozen after travelling to Florida in 100F degree heat. The oysters were all alive, deep cup, very full, very tasty and tasting like the cold ocean off the coast of Maine. Easy to shuck, even easier to eat. I will definitely order from Island Creek again and recommend them without reservation. Well deserved 5 stars!"

— Christian J. (5/5)

Fresh and mild NE oyster

"A perfect starter oyster. Easy to shuck, so fresh, and a nice mild flavor for a northeastern oyster. Good size and great texture."

— Catherine G. (5/5)

Briny

"One of our favorites. Perfect size, deep cups, easy to shuck and taste like the ocean."

— Paul G. (5/5)

Permaquid oysters are "Do agains"

"We thoroughly enjoyed these meaty earthy oysters."

— Christine F. (5/5)

Pemaquid Oysters

"I would recommend these oysters and company wholeheartedly. Out of 150 oysters two were bad the rest were delicious! Was a big hit at our Valentine's Day party!"

— Meredith B. (5/5)

Outstanding Oysters and Service

"All 50 oysters in the order were fresh and delicious. Purchase and shipping efficient and easy. I and friends will certainly be reordering and reordering."

— James S. (5/5)

Absolutely Delicious

"These are some of our favorites. Amazing oysters and farmers. Thanks for all the dedication and hard work."

— Stephen H. (5/5)

Pemaquid Oysters - Yes!

"First time trying Pemaquids. Will order again in the future. Very meaty, medium briny. Very enjoyable."

— Timothy W. (5/5)

well formed shell, easy to open

"they are delicious. probably the most briny oyster, followed by a sweet finish. the meat is plump. definitely a buy again"

— Yoryos Y. (5/5)

Q&A