Home All The North Atlantic Sampler
The North Atlantic Sampler
The North Atlantic Sampler
The North Atlantic Sampler
The North Atlantic Sampler

The North Atlantic Sampler

Sale Price: $119.00

( / )
Unavailable

Please select all options.

 

Sailing down the Eastern Seaboard from our neighbors to the north with a splash of flavor reminiscent of the cold waters in which they're grown, East Cape oysters complete this trio alongside two of our favorites.

This edition of the sampler is a combination of two of our classic oysters, with a unique addition from the north: plump, balanced Island Creeks from right here in Duxbury, plus buttery, creamy Moon Shoals and, salty, bright and clean East Capes. 

WHAT YOU GET:
12 Island Creek Oysters from Duxbury, MA
12 Moon Shoal Oysters from Barnstable, MA
12 East Cape Oysters from Prince Edward Island, CAN

 California Prop 65 Warning

Overall rating: 4.751185 / 5 from 422 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

The North Atlantic Sampler offers a delightful variety of oysters from Duxbury, MA, Barnstable, MA, and Prince Edward Island, CAN. Customers highly recommend this sampler for its exceptional quality, great flavor, and outstanding customer service. The variety and freshness of the oysters are frequently praised, making it a popular choice for gifting.

Summary topics

  • Repeat Order: 13%
  • Oyster Quality: 6%
  • Customer Service: 6%
  • Shipping Speed: 10%
  • Sampler Recommendation: 12%

Review topics: ["flavor","quality","gift","work","shipping","price","packaging","order","deal","variety","treat","service","freshness","sauce","texture","oysters","box","sampler","island creek","ordering","types","wellfleets","experience","hit","choice","differences","moon shoals","instructions","yankee","shucking"].

Review highlights

  • "We love East Coast oysters because of the briny, salty flavors." — James W.
  • "Island Creek is an awesome company." — jd
  • "All three varieties were plump and tasty, true to Island Creek’s reliable quality." — Sue D.

Reviews

Delightful pairing!

"We tried to be fancy. It worked!"

— Paul B. (5/5)

The Sampler

"Was sent as a birthday present and was well received. There was 3 dozen oysters with one that was questionable. . overall very happy!"

— Laurie B. (5/5)

The Duxbury Bay Sampler-A great order

"Was the perfect amount of oysters and variety for just a few of us, and with the same quality that I have come to expect when ordering from Island Creek."

— Brian F. (5/5)

excited

"I was excited to receive this sampler and was also pleased with how easy it was to place the order and receive it without any effort on my part. I was not so happy when it received the order and one of the sampler bags was not labeled. I had forgotten what I ordered and since I was preparing a large dinner didn't have the bandwidth to check it. After shucking I felt that the difference in taste was indistinguishable. I will order again and try others but this first order was kind of a disappointment."

— jan C. (3/5)

Mother shuckers

"Mother shuckers loved island creek oysters on mother’s day"

— Dotty S. (5/5)

Great Sampler

"We enjoyed the mix of oysters, led to nice conversation of what each individual liked or didn’t like in the flavor. Recommend it for small group happy hour."

— Kirsten R. (5/5)

The Duxbury Bay Sampler

"Absolutely incredible Oysters, service was on time and packed perfectly"

— Steven P. (5/5)

So good

"We ordered this for Memorial Day weekend along with some razor clams. We also got a shuck set, which came with some helpful instructions since we had never shucked our own oysters before. Everything arrived exactly on time, and was fresh and intact. The oysters were delicious, so good that we finished three dozen between two of us. Would definitely order this again!"

— Jillian J. (5/5)

Raw Oysters

"Good- not great. Got a few bad ones. We’ve had better from this company."

— Wes H. (3/5)

Awesome selection

"We got the Island Creek Oyster sampler (3 different kinds of oysters). Two were labeled (Aunt Dotty and Honey Drop), but one was not. Unfortunately, the dozen that were not labeled had two bad oysters. Other than that, my wife and son greatly enjoyed them and the caviar."

— Burris E. (3/5)

Q&A